Skip to content
Property

Siblings Fight RM9,300 Buyout of a 1995 Mall Unit Bought at RM231,840

A High Court decision on Dec 2 will determine whether RPM's lawsuit against two unit owners proceeds to trial. The siblings are trying to have the suit struck out before it reaches a full hearing.

Ringgit2U · · 4 min read
abandoned seven-storey shopping complex with broken windows and overgrown entrance
  1. What happened1/6

    Siblings bought a mall unit for RM231,840 in 1995; new owner offers RM9,300

    The Lees purchased Unit 2-21 in a seven-storey shopping complex in Seberang Perai in December 1995 for RM231,840. The building, which includes two basement parking levels, ceased operations around 25 years ago and has been abandoned since.

    RPM acquired the property from Danaharta in 2011, subject to the rights of existing purchasers. Two years ago, RPM offered the siblings RM9,300 for their unit, based on a CBRE WTW Valuation & Advisory Sdn Bhd valuation that factored in the estimated cost of refurbishing the building.

    The dispute is part of a lawsuit RPM filed against 92 defendants in January 2025.

  2. The real numbers2/6

    The numbers behind the RM9,300 offer

    RM231,840purchase price in Dec 1995
    RM9,300RPM acquisition offer
    RM68.6 millionproposed refurbishment cost

    The RM9,300 offer is roughly 4% of what the siblings paid in 1995. RPM pointed to RM10,200.50 in outstanding assessment charges owed to the Seberang Perai City Council (MBSP) as of June 30, 2024. The company wants the pair to either accept the buyout or contribute towards the proposed RM68.6 million refurbishment and lease their unit to RPM once the redevelopment is complete.

  3. abandoned seven-storey shopping complex with broken windows and overgrown entrance
  4. Why it matters3/6

    No strata titles were ever issued for individual units in the complex

    Strata titles were never issued for individual units in the seven-storey complex. The siblings hold contractual rights to Unit 2-21 under their 1995 sale and purchase agreement, but not registered individual ownership of the unit.

    RPM is the sole registered landowner of the entire property. The company bought it from Danaharta in 2011, subject to the rights of purchasers who had already bought units. That gap between contractual rights and registered ownership is the heart of the legal fight.

    RPM says the building had fallen into severe disrepair, with missing doors and windows, accumulated rubbish and frequent trespassing. MBSP had issued notices over the property's condition and warned of possible enforcement action for unpaid assessment charges.

  5. How it works4/6

    RPM leans on the National Land Code; the siblings say it does not apply

    RPM's lawyers rely on a provision of the National Land Code that governs disputes between co-owners of land. The company argues it would be inequitable for it alone to bear the cost of restoring the complex while unit owners stand to benefit from the redevelopment without contributing financially.

    The siblings' lawyers, led by Chong Yew Sheng, counter that the provision is inapplicable because RPM is the sole registered landowner, not a co-owner. Purchasers hold contractual rights to individual units, not registered co-ownership of the land. They also argue RPM cannot demand contributions for refurbishment works that have not yet been carried out.

    1. 01/01
      RM231,840
      purchase price in Dec 1995

      The numbers behind the RM9,300 offer

      purchase price in Dec 1995

  6. How it affects your wallet5/6

    What this means if you bought a unit in an abandoned development

    If you bought a shop lot or office unit from a developer that later collapsed, your name may appear on a sale and purchase agreement but no strata title may exist for your unit. That makes your legal position weaker than a registered owner's.

    A new owner of the land can offer to buy you out at a valuation that factors in the cost of restoring the building. The offer does not have to match what you originally paid. In this case, the RM9,300 figure came from a CBRE WTW valuation that factored in the estimated cost of refurbishing the building.

    Before signing any sale and purchase agreement for a commercial unit, check whether strata titles have been issued or are still pending. Ask the developer in writing and keep the reply. If the building is already abandoned, seek legal advice on your rights under the contract before responding to any buyout offer.

  7. What to watch6/6

    High Court decision on whether the suit proceeds is set for Dec 2

    The High Court has fixed Dec 2 for a decision on whether RPM's suit against the two unit owners should proceed to trial. The siblings are seeking to strike out the suit against them, arguing RPM has no legal basis to force them to accept either the buyout or the refurbishment contribution.

Questions people ask

Why was the shop lot valued at only RM9,300?

The valuation by CBRE WTW Valuation & Advisory Sdn Bhd factored in the estimated cost of refurbishing the abandoned building. The complex had been shut for about 25 years, with missing doors and windows, accumulated rubbish and frequent trespassing.

Can a new owner force me to sell my unit without a strata title?

That is the central legal question in this case. RPM relies on a National Land Code provision for co-owners disputes. The siblings argue it does not apply because RPM is the sole registered landowner. The Dec 2 hearing only decides whether the suit proceeds to trial; the substantive question would be settled at trial.

What are assessment charges and who is responsible for them?

Assessment charges are fees levied by local councils such as MBSP for services like waste collection and road maintenance. In this case, RM10,200.50 was outstanding as of June 30, 2024. RPM cited the unpaid charges as part of the property's deteriorating condition.

Source: KWSP (EPF)Free Malaysia Today

Keep reading